brand
Call For A Free Phone Consultation
617-297-9213
atty-banner

Former Prosecutors, Aggressively Fighting For You

atty-banner
  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Articles
  4.  » Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Decides for Driver In DUI Question

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Decides for Driver In DUI Question

In Massachusetts, if you are pulled over under suspicion of DUI or OUI, you will be given the option to take a breathalyzer test, during which two breath samples are taken. Two samples are taken so the accuracy of one can be checked against the other.

If the two breath samples differ by more than 0.02 percent, the results are deemed to be inaccurate and inadmissible in court. If the samples are within 0.02 percent of each other, then they may be considered to be accurate — but only the lower reading is used as evidence in court.

Earlier this year, Dennis Steele was pulled over under suspicion of drunk driving. He was tested with a breathalyzer — blowing 0.09 percent blood alcohol content (BAC) on his first try and 0.10 just a moment later. In accordance with Massachusetts statute, the lower reading was admitted into evidence.

However, prosecuting attorneys representing Franklin and Hampshire Counties attempted to include the higher BAC reading during the trial, citing its importance as evidence. After Mr. Steele’s conviction, the case found itself before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

In Commonwealth vs. Dennis P. Steele, the highest court in the state found on behalf of Mr. Steele, upholding the original statute and rendering the higher BAC reading inadmissible.

There has been some dissatisfaction among law enforcement agencies with this ruling, but it’s important to remember why two readings are taken in the first place. Two readings are required to ensure the accuracy or “validity” of the breathalyzer test — not to attain additional evidence. If too large a gap is found between the first and second reading, a more accurate reading should be sought to be used as evidence.

Further, many questions have been raised recently on how well breathalyzer tests report actual BAC. The accuracy of breath tests largely depends on the officer administrating the test and the overall quality of the testing device itself. A higher reading may not be the result of under-estimated BAC, but improper use of the breathalyzer and/or a miscalculation.

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court based its decision on a desire to uphold the current state statute already in place and to avoid courtroom confusion. While the ruling does, technically, benefit drivers, it does not seem to do so at the expense of public safety.

Bg Quote

Client Testimonials

Bg Stars

In the most painful times in our lives–David, Greg and Lisa showed us their professional best–dignified, warm, gracious. David and his team will not let you down, you will be taken well care of and most importantly superbly and justly represented…
Barbara Lynch

Oh my goodness David is a miracle worker! Unbelievable results! David is so highly respected by attorneys and judges and prosecutors that he really makes an impact in court and presented our friend in the best possible light…

Jude Dasilva

Greg Johnson and David Yannetti are simply the best. After having two other attorneys on a case, I hired them and got results where others failed. They work hard for you and I highly recommend them!…

Vivian Trinh

If it was not for Mr. Yannetti I could have lost my career and opportunity to come back to USA again given that I am not a US citizen. Thank you Mr. Yannetti for all you did for me and my family. You and your office were truly there for me in my darkest hour…

Ajit Gupta

Greg Johnson is a charming attorney and seems to truly care about his client’s and the outcome of their case. If you ever need an experienced criminal defense Lawyer, Yannetti Criminal Defense Law Firm is the one to call!…

Ramone

“I’ve got your back,” he told me early on. David did not disappoint. By showing up with David in the courtroom, I felt I’d made a clear statement of intent. The case was duly dropped…

James Brooks

Martindale-Hubbell | AV Preeminent | Peer Rated for Highest Level of Professional Excellence | 2020
The Best Lawyers In America
Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb | Top Attorney Criminal Defense
Super Lawyers
Fox News | Criminal Defense Analyst
CNN | Criminal Defense Analyst
ID | Investigation Discovery | Consultant
Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly | Criminal Defense Expert